...because home doesn't happen overnight.

Wow.  When I thought about asking for your help in determining which Underdog room to use as my design school guinea pig, I wasn’t expecting such fervent participation.  I don’t write this blog for the numbers, so I rarely look at them. Which, apparently, isn’t a good idea because I was just notified yesterday by my web hosting provider that H*T content/traffic is getting to be too much for them to handle and that I should consider switching my service to another provider that can better suit H*T’s needs.  Now, that’s an honest company.

Anyhow, I had guessed that maybe ~300 votes would enter into the poll since that seems to be the current going rate for giveaway entries. Imagine my surprise when I checked the final tally on Friday and discovered over 900 entries!  You guys rock.  Thanks for taking the time to put in your two cents.  Here are the final results:

Living Room:  476 votes

Dining Room/Mudroom:  361 votes

Master Bedroom:  86 votes

The living room design will become my school guinea pig.  This is the room I was leaning towards on my own, so I’m glad the majority of you think it’s a good choice as well.  I agree that the dining room/mudroom/laundry nook/craft room will be the most difficult to design just because of all the purposes it will serve.  It will definitely be nice to have another, slightly easier room under my belt to boost my confidence before taking on such a huge challenge.  If you’re one of the dining room/mudroom or master bedroom voters, don’t fret.  Even though these rooms won’t be my official school project, they’re still getting made over and I plan on sharing their progress as well.  Different steps of each room’s makeover may be happening simultaneously, too.  So, it’s not like I’m going to focus only on the living room until it is 100% finito before I do anything to a different room.  The living room will just get the design school special treatment so I can share what I’m learning.

Over the 4th of July holiday, I took pictures and measurements of the living room – the first step in designing any room. Today I’ll share the pictures and briefly discuss what I’m seeing and thinking in each one.

As you already know by now, the living room is a room within a room…i.e., it will be open to the eat-in kitchen.  Since we removed the wall separating the living room from the kitchen, that leaves only three perimeter walls.  Rooms that are open like this tend to make furniture arrangement tricky as you have one less wall to contain the room’s contents and traffic. And since the living room will be obviously visible from the kitchen, it will have to meld well with the kitchen’s aesthetic for a cohesive feel.

Here are the three living room walls in detail.

This wall houses the fireplace and mantel and creates a natural focal point.

Furniture placement and other design elements {lighting, accessories, paint, etc.} should punctuate this feature.

This wall contains the front door and a large picture window.  As is, the front door is heavy and dark, obstructing the view to the front yard and not allowing optimal light to pass through.  The window provides tons of natural light.  Any added window treatments should not impede the flow of light into the space.

The window will act as a focal point when looking into the living room from the kitchen area, so any window treatments should pick up on that.

This is the third and final living room wall, opposite the fireplace.  This is where guests will enter into the home so it needs to act {functionally and aesthetically} as a small entry.  The narrow doorway leads to a hall that houses the bedrooms and bathrooms and cannot be blocked by furniture.

So, that’s a closer look at the living room.  The shell and architecture of this room are rather basic with a fireplace and window taking center stage.  I’ll share a rough sketch and room dimensions soon!

What are your thoughts on making over the living room?  Any ideas?

images: all Dana Miller for House*Tweaking

19 Comments

07.July.2011

A good sectional, I think would be one alternative. We have a long, linear living room, but short on the width side of things. Our sectional breaks up the room and gives definition without putting up a literal barrier. It creates flow for traffic and keeps the room’s open feel. Good luck!

What a great room to work with! That room is going to look amazing with the vaulted ceiling. I like your idea of track lighting along the ridge but I’d also add a dropped chandelier, sort of like what Sarah Richardson did in her farmhouse, to anchor the space a bit more:
http://razmatazblog.blogspot.com/2010/04/sarah-richardsons-farmhouse-part-6the.html

You can easily define the open space with furniture… a sofa with its back to the entry, two arm chairs facing the window, a generous ottoman, maybe a daybed beneath the window so you don’t obscure the great view. It has a lot of potential!

What do you plan on doing with the fireplace? Will you cover the brick?

Oops, I meant chaise, not daybed (unless its a Barcelona!), beneath the window.

07.July.2011

I am by no means qualified to give any kind of decoration advice but here goes my humble opinion. I think some sort of multi function (storage space for books, etc) “room divider” would look nice to create a more defined space between the entryway and living room – on the left side just as you walk in from the door. We have this one from IKEA and love how it can be used horizontally as well. http://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/50103086#/60156282
Also, a nice low profile sofa(s) across from the picture window would help a lot in mainting the feel of an open space that doesn’t feel cluttered. I love IKEA so here’s another link: http://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/80119463
For more seating options, maybe a few low lying chaise chairs on each side of the picture window would look nice and function nicely (i.e. allows for people to see each other face-to-face when chatting) while again, allowing for that open feel you’re trying to maintain. That’s my 2cents! :)
Best of luck.

I agree with Jen on the dropped chandelier idea- gorgeous light fixtures can make an entire room!

07.July.2011

Ooooo, I love bare spaces.

I’m better at functionality than at decor, so here are some ideas about that.

You’ll need a place for shoes/keys/chargers/muddy boots/ coats etc either to the right of the door or between the door and the entry to the bedroom area. Is there room for some kind of closet in the bedroom hall area? You’d still need a landing pad, but not such an industrial strength one.

If your sofa faced the fireplace with its back to the entry, you could put a low range of bookcases behind it, for additional storage for shoes or kidstuff. Or a console table with a couple of small ottomans under it, if additional seating is more important.

A long low bench with storage underneath and cushions on top under the window, would be a way to add more seating without taking up much space. And the storage could include some shoe/ boot storage in some kind of attractive disguise. And/or kidstuff.

The fireplace wall takes up a lot of space without contributing much in the way of storage/function. Beauty is good, but in a small space even beauty has to do its share of the work. I also am a little concerned about the strong horizontal of the bricks once the ceiling is removed. You’ll want something to emphasize that vertical height that doesn’t fight with the dark horizontal of bricks. Also, it would be nice if that wall could have some function added, either with bookcases or … something on either side of the fireplace, maybe just above the brick. If your tv is going in this room (I can’t remember if it’s in this room or the dining and everything else room), then the fireplace wall is the place for it. Maybe in the corner between the fp wall and the window wall. Or you could build up above the fireplace with the tv mounted to the wall and shelving around it so it doesn’t just leap out at you.

Out of curiosity, what is the filled in area above the fireplace? Was there a window there that was taken out when the fireplace was added? Or has the fireplace always been there?

What fun to be able to drop ideas, then run while someone else does all the work and makes all the decisions. Thanks.

Your last photo is similar to the entry at my place, except out kitchen is on the other side of that wall. We don’t have a single coat closet in the whole house, so I built a coat rack with a ledge spanning the entire wall. Our family and guests can hang coats and bags there and the ledge can be used to hold art. You can take a peek at it here: http://explanationrequired.blogspot.com/2011/05/build-something-from-scratch-check.html

I can’t wait to see your living room (heck, your whole house) come together!!

07.July.2011

Hm… looking at the pictures of your living room inspirations stuck me!

What would you think of painting the fireplace brick the Benjamin Moore Newburg Green you posted about (if you are thinking of painting it at all, that is)?? I think it would look AMAZING with some bright white trim, the (what looks like) granite mantle, and a lighter more neutral color on the walls (like a lighter grey or darker cream color maybe?). It would also make the fireplace stand out alot providing a great focal point.

Just an idea that I thought I’d share. Good luck with all your design planning! :)

07.July.2011

This isn’t living room-related but it does affect layout so I thought I’d ask . . .
I know you said you want an indoor laundry area and are therefore going to put the laundry closet back, but that breaks up the space so much!!! Why not leave that wall out between the kitchen and dining room, put a bar/countertop combo on that side of the kitchen (with stool seating on the dining/mudroom side, obv) and just do a front-loading washer/dryer in cabinetry underneath? Open(er) floor plan, lets the light flow through, and the cabinetry should block as much washer/dryer noise as any closet would.

07.July.2011

I just recently found your blog, but I’m so excited to follow you in your progress with this home! How exciting!

Dana this room has sooooo much potential. I love all the ideas that others have said already. I’m seeing a couch with two chairs or just a nice sectional. Something under the window for seating and storage. I love sitting in front of a window to read or just relax. The entryway area, if you had the couch back to that wall then I would put some sort of storage or extra seating. Maybe a nice coat rack on the entry wall. Maybe that wall could have a half wall of wainscotting or something like that to your taste with the coat rack to dress it up. It might help to define the entry wall when you walk in. Are you painting the brick white? Covering it? I also love the idea of a chandlier in this room. It will really bring your eye up. I can’t wait to see how this room comes together….heck I can’t wait to see what they whole house will look like. Can’t wait to see your ideas for this room. The playing part is always stressful, but it’s so much fun to put a room together and to see it evolve over time. Lots of luck on this project!!! :-)

08.July.2011

Hey Dana, Im sure you’ve got a million great design ideas, but have you considered making your laundry “closet” an islandish cabinet to house the appliances and give yourself more countertop space and open up to the den( I think). If you google “laundry in kitchen” you might find some great ideas…I saw you mention the radon appartus, but you might figure something out. Just a thought!

08.July.2011

All great ideas. I like Cara’s ideas for storage and additional seating. I see the fireplace wall as one smooth surface with a beautiful stone/concrete/wood material on the ledge and on the hearth area. But then again I like a more streamlined aesthetic. Do not know if that fits in with yours.
We hope to build our dream home (modestly-sized) within the next year or so thus I am watching your home evolve much anticipation.

If I had not been following your blog and the transformation of the under dog…I might think you were doing a total basement remodel with those cinder block walls…

Looking forward to seeing what you come up with for your design project…

09.July.2011

Denyse – I know, it does look like a basement, doesn’t it?!

09.July.2011

Katie – That coat rack/ledge is amazing!!! I just might have to borrow your idea!

09.July.2011

Caro – LOVE all the ideas you presented! Some of them, I’ve even got up my sleeve ;) The fireplace is original to the home and the ‘filled in’ area is just the chimney area. I definitely agree that there needs to be some sort of vertical element to balance out all that horizontal brick along the fireplace wall. I’ll be sharing my idea for that, don’t worry. The TV will be going in this room and we’re 99% positive that it will be going above the fireplace. Thanks for such wonderful ideas! I love ’em!

11.July.2011

You probably already have this suggestion…but how about sheetrocking the fireplace brick. Creating a new surround with some beautiful glass tile, and plopping a heavy mantle on the top of the current LOONNGG brick span. Then framing in some bookshelves to the left and right on the current long span above the brick. You’ll have a lovely place for nick nacks, books, baskets whatever, plus…a clean fireplace look, AND…a lovely little niche to hang a television (I’m a TV in the livingroom person as long as it’s neat looking), mirror or HUGE piece of art…:)

11.July.2011

Dawn – All of those ideas sound lovely! We have just started throwing around ideas for the fireplace/mantel wall. I definitely want to add a vertical element that will offset the horizontal lines of the fireplace and brick. The built-ins you mentioned would be one option. Hmmm….we’ll just have to see what happens.